Pizza is one of the most popular and beloved foods worldwide, and it’s no different in Whitby. To help you narrow your search, we’ve compiled a guide to the best pizza in Whitby.
We’ve scoured the town to find the top pizzerias taking into consideration factors like taste, quality, and customer service. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, check out our recommendations for the best pizza in Whitby.
This picturesque town has pizza for everyone, from traditional-style wood-fired pizzas to creative gourmet toppings. Knowing where to start can be frustrating with so many options, so we’ve compiled this guide to help you.
FREE Whitby Mini-Guide
"Get the best from your stay in Whitby." - Everything you need to know about Whitby into a free mini-guide!
Pizza restaurants in Whitby
Pizza West
Vegetarian and Vegan options | Family-friendly | Perfect for family celebrations
Located on West Cliff in Whitby, Pizza West has received outstanding reviews since its opening in 2021. The food and service provided at Pizza West are exceptional, with delicious pizzas and fresh toppings made from local ingredients wherever possible, including some unique ingredients. The menu offers various pizza options, including meat and seafood, and all meals are beautifully presented. The prices are incredibly reasonable, and the portion sizes are generous. We recommend the Pil Pil prawn and nduja, San Marzano tomatoes, and mozzarella pizza. It’s out of this world!
Moutrey’s
Vegetarian and Vegan options | Family-friendly | Perfect for romantic meals
Moutrey’s is a popular destination for visitors to Whitby, and it’s easy to see why. Whether you’re looking for a romantic evening with your partner, a family get-together, or a celebration with friends, Moutreys is the perfect spot. Their freshly prepared food is cooked in a wood-fired oven, adding authenticity and flavour to their delicious homely Italian cuisine. From hearty meat dishes to fresh seafood, Moutreys always uses local ingredients where possible. The service is fantastic, but booking in advance during peak times is recommended due to its popularity. We love the Cajun pizza here: tomato, mozzarella, Cajun chicken, red onions, garlic, and wild mushrooms. Perfect if, like us, you like a little spice!
Cosa Nostra
Vegetarian and Vegan options | Family-friendly | Perfect for family gatherings
Cosa Nostra is a local, family-run restaurant in Whitby that offers a relaxed atmosphere and serves high-quality Italian cuisine. The restaurant is housed in a beautiful Grade II listed building spread over two floors, creating an inviting and charming ambience. Cosa Nostra prides itself on using locally sourced ingredients to prepare fresh meals. It is a perfect option for various occasions, whether you want to escape the sea breeze after a long hike or celebrate a special event with friends and family. We love the Pollo alla Kiev pizza here, its tomato, mozzarella, chicken, mushrooms, and garlic. Delicious!
Whitby Brewery
Vegetarian and Vegan options | Family-friendly | Perfect for pizza with a view
When the sun is shining, Whitby Brewery is the ideal spot to enjoy great beer, pizza, live music, and stunning views of the Abbey.
They serve freshly prepared, stone-baked pizza, hand-stretched to order. Our pick was the mouthwatering Prosciutto pizza. Whether you prefer vegan, vegetarian, or extra spicy options, they have got you covered; just let them know your preference!
They welcome dogs inside and out. We thoroughly enjoyed the laid-back atmosphere for a couple of pints and a pizza.
Visit the Whitby Brewery website
Takeaway pizza in Whitby
Bitz N Pizzas
Vegetarian and Vegan options | Pick-up and delivery
In the heart of Whitby, Bitz N Pizzas stands out as one of the top takeaways in the area. This traditional takeaway restaurant, located on Flowergate, offers a variety of dishes to cater to different tastes. Of course, their pizza selection is extensive, featuring pizzas such as tropical chicken, red sax and American hot. However, you can also choose from Italian classics such as cheese and tomato pizza, wraps, and burgers. They also feature kids’ meals. With such a diverse menu, Bitz N Pizzas is an excellent choice for a satisfying takeaway meal in Whitby.
Visit the Bitz n Pizzas website
Porto Pizza
Vegetarian and Vegan options | Pick-up and delivery
Porto Pizza is a popular takeaway known for its delicious pizzas; this restaurant offers a variety of options to cater to different tastes. The pizzas are made using fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. In addition to traditional pizza toppings, Porto Pizza offers unique and creative toppings such as prawns and anchovies! Well, you are in Whitby, after all. The menu also features burgers, kebabs, garlic bread and a kid’s menu. With affordable prices and fast service, Porto Pizza is an excellent option after exploring Whitby.
In conclusion, Whitby is a town that has no shortage of great pizza places, each with its unique twist on this Italian classic. So, whether you’re looking for a sit-down restaurant or a takeaway spot, there are plenty of options. From the freshly prepared pizzas at Moutreys to the locally sourced ingredients at Pizza West or the diverse menu at Bitz N Pizzas, every pizza lover will find a spot that satisfies their cravings. Whitby is a pizza paradise, and we encourage you to try out as many fantastic pizza places as possible!
Related Posts